The Upper Crust | Penfield, NY

We will be open on Valentine’s Day (Mon Feb 14)

11:00am - 4:00pm

Swing by anytime, to pickup some of our holiday specialities to share with your sweetie.

We have changed our hours. It is similar to before, except we are opening a little later in the mornings.

Our new schedule is:

Sunday - closed

Monday - closed

Tuesday - by appointment

Wednesday - 10:00am to 6:00pm

Thursday - 10:00am to 6:00pm

Friday - 10:00am to 6:00pm

Saturday - 10:00am to 6:00pm

We will be closed tomorrow (Friday Jan 21) due to an unexpected family matter. We will resume our regular hours on Saturday 8am. We sincerely apologize for any inconvenience this may cause.

We will be closed on Saturday, Jan 1. Come visit us in the New Year, when we resume our regular business hours next week!

We will be open this week (Christmas week) . . . .

Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday

8:00am - 6:00pm

Friday (Christmas Eve)

8:00am - 3:00pm

We will be closed for the weekend and reopen on Wed Dec 29, just in time to help you celebrate New Year’s!

We’re still accepting orders for Christmas! Next week (Christmas week) we will be open Tuesday - Friday, 8:00am - 6:00pm.

We also have most items available for purchase in-store, during regular business hours.

Centerpiece Cakes

Use one of these beautiful cakes for your holiday  centerpiece, or bring one to the upcoming work party! We also have larger sizes available.

Poinsettia Design, Snowflake Design, or Snowman Design*

6″ single torte, serves about 4-6, $20.00

6″ double torte, serves about 8, $35.00

* add $5.00.

Miniature Cupcake Assortment

This is a collection of all ten flavors of our Colossal Cupcakes, simply a smaller version of each! Vanilla, Chocolate, Twist, Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Lemon Raspberry, Pollyanna, Carrot, Pumpkin Spice, and Black & White. $18.00/box

Holiday Assortment Tray

Featuring a dozen each of our mini cupcakes (see above), small chocolate and peppermint-frosted brownie squares, and Winter Cut-Outs, this is perfect for an office thank-you or neighborly gift. Medium  12″ tray serves about 12, $50.00.

Nativity Cut-Out Collection

A very special family of three is surrounded by wooly sheep, angels and stars! $18.00/dz

Christmas Classics

We bring you some of our family’s favorite Christmas-time cookie traditions: Hershey’s Chocolate Hugs, Peanut-Butter Blossoms, Rum-Spice Logs, Raspberry Shortbread, and CrinkleMint sandwiches. $9.00/dz

Rudolph & Friends Cut-Out Collection

Inspired by the annual television special, we proudly present Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, Hermie the Elf, Mr Sam Snowman, Yukon Cornelius, and of course the Abominable Snow Monster, all in delightful cookie form! $18.00/dozen

Santa & Friends Cut-Out Collection

The kids will love this fun cookie collection, including Santa, his sleigh, and all 9 of his reliable reindeer (Rudolph, too!).  $18.00/dozen

Assorted Christmas Classics Cookie Tins

Can’t find the time to make those cookies for the neighbors or co-workers? Save yourself some trouble and order some of these ready-to-give gifts. We package a lovely assortment of our Christmas Classics, (plus some Cut-Outs too!) in a light blue tin with see-through lid and finish with silver Christmas ribbon.

[ Small White Box, 8 cookies, $7.00 ]

Medium Tin, 18 cookies, $16.00

Large Tin, 36 cookies, $31.00

Winter Cut-Out Collection

One of our most popular collections, these classic Christmas designs are sure to put a smile on everyone’s face. Including snowman, stocking, tree, mitten, and gingerbread house shapes, these make an impressive dessert or even intriguing place setting markers! $18.00/dozen

Ornament Cut-Out Collection

These cookies come in a variety of ornament shapes and are decorated in an elegant color scheme with hunter green, holly-berry red, and deep purple. $15.00/dozen

Snowflake Cut-Out Collection

These snowflake cookies come in a assortment of varying sizes and shapes. They are iced in white and pale blue buttercream, and are decorated with sparking sugar “snow crystals” or hand piped snowflake designs. $15.00/dozen

Please note that we recommend storing the cutout cookies in the refrigerator or freezer, as the cold temperatures will best preserve the icing decorations. (The buttercream tends to soften at room temp.) You can take them directly out to serve at the last possible moment or display ahead of time in a single layer without stacking.

OUR NEW LOCATION HAS SPECIAL HOURS FOR THANKSGIVING WEEK!

Although our normal business hours are Wed-Sat (8am-6pm), we’re offering an extended schedule this week because of the Thanksgiving holiday.

We are open Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday for you to stop by for some holiday treats; as well as Friday and Saturday. We are closed on Thanksgiving Day (Thursday).

Our hours are the same every day that we are open: 8:00am - 6:00pm.

Please note we are completely booked for special orders through this weekend. So instead, feel free to stop by and pick out some goodies from our display cases! We intend to have all 10 flavors of our Colossal Cupcakes, as well as Harvest & Pilgrim cut-out cookies, our Pumpkin Spice bread, and some Thanksgiving Centerpiece cakes, too. Come check it out!

Don’t forget to stop by for free cupcakes and coffee at our new shop!

This is a working list of our in-store products, available during regular business hours beginning this Sat Nov 20.

Please note that the photos are examples only, just to give you an idea. Actual items in-store are similar but may vary in color and design. Information, prices, and photos subject to change without notice.

Colossal Cupcakes

Prepare your eyes to widen and consider yourself warned: these cupcakes could be described as LARGE, IMPRESSIVE, and DELICIOUS. Several times bigger than a standard size cupcake, they are the perfect treat for you and a friend to share. Or, bring an assortment to that weekend dinner party to wow the hostess. We take our time in creating these, to bring you a quality product that always tastes fresh and moist, as well as being consistently decorated with precision and care.

We will have all 10 flavors available regularly, as well as baking up a special “Wild Card” flavor from time to time (think Black-Forest, Chocolate Peppermint, Vanilla Raspberry!). Colossal Cupcakes are sold individually (pricing below, although we are happy to offer a significant quantity discounts for purchases of half or full dozen.

Vanilla - white vanilla cake filled and iced in vanilla buttercream (edged with white sparkling sugar)

Chocolate - chocolate cake filled and iced in chocolate fudge buttercream (edged in chocolate sprinkles)

Twist - marble cake filled and iced in vanilla and chocolate buttercream (swirl icing)

Pollyanna - golden vanilla cake filled with vanilla buttercream and iced in chocolate fudge buttercream (edged with rainbow sprinkles)

Carrot - carrot cake filled and iced in cream cheese (decorated with buttercream carrots on top)

Cookies & Cream - chocolate cake with Oreo cookie pieces, filled with chocolate fudge buttercream, iced in vanilla Oreo buttercream, topped with an Oreo cookie.

Pumpkin Spice - pumpkin spice cake filled and iced in cream-cheese (decorated with a buttercream pumpkin on top)

Chocolate Peanut Butter - chocolate cake filled with chocolate fudge buttercream and iced in peanut butter buttercream, dipped in ganache and topped with more Reeses candies

Black & White - chocolate cake filled with chocolate fudge buttercream and iced in cream-cheese, then dipped in ganache

Lemon Raspberry - lemon citrus cake filled with raspberry and iced in a light raspberry buttercream (edged with white sparkling sugar)

$3.75/each | $20.00/six | $38.00/twelve

WHOLE CAKES

We know that sometimes last minute celebrations come up, without time to place an advance order. So, we’re bringing you some of our most popular cakes ready for spontaneous pickup. Although they are decorated beautifully as-is, we are happy to write any inscription on-the-spot per your request.

Flavors include: White Vanilla, Chocolate Fudge, and Sampler (8 slices of Vanilla, Chocolate, Lemon & Carrot)

6″ single-layer serves about 4, $20.00

6″ double-layer serves about 8, $35.00

6″ double-layer SAMPLER, serves about 8, $40.00

CUTOUTS

Our soft and buttery shaped cookies continue to be one of our most popular products, and we’d like to bring them to you in the store-front. We decorate them with vanilla and chocolate buttercream, paying close attention to the unusual details that make these so special.

Standard Flower 3″ ($1.00/each)

Small Flower 2″ ($0.75/each)

Tiered Cake 3″ ($3.00/each)

Seasonal, simple ($1.00/each)

Seasonal, detailed ($1.50/each)

Crinkle Cut with sprinkles ($0.75/each)

As with our Colossal Cupcakes, we do offer a discount on full dozen quantity.

BREADS

Long before the Upper Crust Cakery was officially established, we had the beginnings of the business involved in the local Fairport Farmer’s Market. For several summers, each Saturday we brought homemade yeast and quick breads to the community. It became evident there were a few favorites in particular, and we’re bringing them back for your enjoyment.

Cinnamon Sensation ($3.00/each or full dozen for $30.00)

Pumpkin Spice, Large Loaf ($8.75/each)

Pumpkin Spice, Small Loaf ($4.00/each)

SPECIALTY COOKIES & BROWNIES

Although cake and cupcakes remain our primary focus at the Upper Crust Cakery, we are passionate about producing tasty cookie and brownie classics as well. Sometimes cookies are just the thing, eliminating the need to cut a cake or remember to bring forks. These are available individually, or we can put together a boxed assortment for you. Please note that we take special care to ensure our cookies are baked soft and chewy, to keep them moist and delicious for your enjoyment.

COOKIES

Classic Chocolate Chip

Chocolate Crinkle

M & M

Oatmeal Raisin

BROWNIES

Chocolate-Frosted Brownie, reg. size 2″ square

Peppermint-Frosted Brownie, reg. size 2″ square

All specialty cookies and brownies are $1.50/each or $15.00/dozen.

Please note that the photos are examples only, just to give you an idea. Actual items in-store are similar but may vary in color and design. Information, prices, and photos subject to change without notice.

The Upper Crust Cakery

Open House

this Saturday, November 20

8:00am - 6:00pm

Come visit us for the unveiling of our new location! After several months of remodeling, painting, and planning, we are finally set to open the shop this weekend. The cakery will be open all day, so stop by anytime. Bring your family and friends for free cupcakes and hot coffee. We’ll have balloons for the kids and some awesome cake giveaways! You’re also welcome to browse our display cases and purchase something to take home and enjoy.

We will continue to take advance special orders as before. In addition, the storefront will be open to the general public. Our retail hours will be Wednesdays through Saturdays 8:00am-6:00pm (beginning Saturday Nov. 20). We are closed on Sundays and Mondays, and by-appointment-only on Tuesdays. Next week, however, is Thanksgiving and so our special holiday schedule will be Monday through Wednesday, and Friday through Saturday (closed on Thanksgiving Day).

Our new shop is located at 1793 Penfield Road (south-side of Rt. 441) in Penfield 4 Corners. It’s a little light-brown building directly in between Joey’s Pasta House and the new Joey’s Party House. We share the parking lot there and there are plenty of spots. You can turn directly off Rt. 441 into the driveway. OR, take the “secret entrance” by turning off Five-Mile-Line-Road onto Mott’s Lane, which runs behind all the businesses and connects to the parking lots.

We have some very fun options for spontaneous walk-in clients, that will be available at all times. Our display cases contain a variety of delicious items ready for on-the-spot purchase, including 10 over-the-top flavors of jumbo cupcakes, our famous cut-out butter cookies, and chocolate-fudge and peppermint-frosted brownies just to name a few. [There is a subsequent post coming with complete item and price list of our retail products.]

Thank you for your continued patronage and enthusiasm for the Upper Crust Cakery. We are so excited to have a new presence in the Penfield community, and we look forward to unveiling it this weekend. Mark your calendar to stop by this Saturday!