The Upper Crust | Penfield, NY

There’s still time to order your Thanksgiving treats! Contact us via email or phone. It’s not too late!

Bunny Cupcakes

The kids will love these! Each vanilla cupcake is iced in vanilla buttercream, and decorated with a bunny cut-out cookie holding an armful of candy carrots.

Each serves 1. $2.75/each. Half dozen minimum, please.

Cinnamon Sensations

Our famous “sticky buns” are overflowing with cinnamon sugar and real butter, and topped with a lavish swirl of creamy icing. These also freeze very well, so order a few extra to stash away!

$2.25/each. Half dozen minimum, please.

Easter Basket Cake

This unique, 3-dimensional creation is actually two layers of moist carrot cake, decorated in a basketweave pattern with cream cheese icing, and topped with Easter egg cut-out cookies! Wonderful as a table centerpiece. (Also available in alternate cake/icing flavors.)

6″ round serves about 10 ~ $35.00

8″ round serves about 20 ~ $45.00

Lemon Poppyseed Bread

Made with real lemons and a generous amount of poppy seeds, this light, flavorful sweet bread is perfect to complement your Easter brunch or dinner.

Large loaf (yields 8-10 slices) ~ $8.75

Easter Cut-Outs

An exquisite assortment of Easter eggs, bunnies, carrots, and daisy flowers is guaranteed to brighten your Easter celebration!

$12.00/dozen

Celebration Cake

This vanilla cake is iced in our vanilla buttercream and decorated with a variety of sugar flowers as a beautiful spring wreath.

8″ round serves about 15 ~ $45.00

Cookie Assortment

Lemon bar squares, raspberry shortbread cookies, and a smaller version of our delicious cut-out daisies make up this appealing assortment of bite-size spring treats.

Available boxed or trayed ~ $7.00/dozen . 2 dozen minimum, please

St. Patrick’s Day is next Tuesday, March 17!

Rainbow Cake

With a colorful cut-out cookie rainbow and marshmallow pot ‘o gold, this happy cake is sure to delight all your family or friends! 6″ two-layer round serves about 6-8, $35.00

Shamrock Cupcakes

These vanilla cupcakes are baked in gold liners, iced with a generous swirl of vanilla buttercream, and decorated with some jolly St. Patrick’s Day shamrock sprinkles. $1.50/each (half dozen minimum, please)

Mint-Frosted Brownies

One of our most popular desserts, these luscious little goodies are home-made brownie squares iced in mint buttercream and served in shamrock-themed papers. $5.00/dozen (apprx. 1″ squares- two dozen minimum, please)

Lucky Cut-Outs

Here’s a fun holiday mix of shamrocks, rainbows, pots o’ gold, and pointy-eared leprechauns! $12.00/dozen

Valentine’s Day is only two weeks away!

Order today to surprise your Valentine. She’ll love you forever.

Petit Fours
For an elegant treat, try these little dark chocolate cake squares, enveloped in smooth, semi-sweet chocolate ganache. $15.00/dozen (one dozen minimum, please)

Valentine Cut-Outs
These heart shaped butter cookies (in varying sizes) are individually decorated with great detail, and
are sure to please your Valentine.
$12.00/dozen

Chocolate & Roses Cake
This is our moist dark chocolate cake iced in chocolate fudge buttercream. Exquisitely decorated with buttercream roses and an intricate scroll pattern, this cake will delight any chocolate lover. 6″ round serves 8 - $35.00

Heart Cupcakes
Perfect for the kids’ classroom or the girls at the office, these cupcakes are iced in vanilla or chocolate fudge buttercream, sprinkled with hearts, and finished off with a heart cut-out cookie! Each serves 1. Chocolate or vanilla. $2.25/each (6 minimum per flavor, please)

Valentine Bear Cakes
Imagine what the kids would think!
These edible bears are actually dark chocolate cake iced in chocolate fudge buttercream,
each clutching a heart cut-out cookie! Each serves 1-2. $7.50/each

Dessert Boxes

Packaged in a white bakery box tied with Valentine ribbon, these amazing assortments include miniature versions of 4 desserts:
Mint frosted brownies, classic chocolate chip cookies, chocolate crinkle cookies,
and heart-shaped cut-outs. Guaranteed to entice any grateful recipient! (Note: we wanted to use the polka dot boxes shown in the picture, but unfortunately they have been discontinued by our supplier.)
Sm. box (about 1 dz) ~ $8.00

Med. box (about 2 dz) ~ $15.00

Large box (about 4 dz) ~ $28.00

NOTE: We are no longer accepting further orders (including Christmas or otherwise) through Sunday, January 4. We will resume taking orders for the new year, on Monday, January 5.

Christmas is coming soon! Order today.

Winter Cake
This dark chocolate cake is iced in vanilla buttercream and decorated with sugared pine cones and chocolate pine needles.

8″ two-layer square serves about 20, $50. 6″ square serves about 12, $35.

Ornament Cupcakes
These vanilla cupcakes are iced in vanilla buttercream and covered with rolled fondant.

They are hand painted with edible glitter and decorated to look like a real Christmas ornament.
$4.50/each (half dozen minimum, please)

Winter Cut-Outs
An assortment including holiday shapes

like snowman, candy cane, star, wreath, snowflake, and mitten. $12.00/dozen

Santa Cut-Outs
The kids will love this fun cookie collection, including Santa, his sleigh, and all 9 of his reliable reindeer (Rudolph, too!).  $12.00/dozen

Cookie Boxes
Can’t find the time to make those cookies for the neighbors or co-workers? Order a few boxes of ours- an assortment of Cocoa Crinkles (filled with chocolate buttercream and rolled in crushed candy canes), Mint Brownies, Raspberry Shortbread, and Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip squares.

About 1 dozen in each glossy white box, tied with festive Christmas ribbon. $8.00/each

Snowman Cupcakes
These dark chocolate cupcakes are iced in vanilla buttercream and decorated with an adorable marshmallow snowman on top.

With a chocolate mint beret hat, who could resist? $2.00/each (half dozen minimum, please)

Christmas Eve Cake
Don’t forget to leave Santa his cocoa and cookies!

Along with the 3-D sculpted cake “mug”, this 10″ single-layer (vanilla) round iced in chocolate buttercream, serves about 12, $40.

Thanksgiving Day is coming up soon! Contact us today to place your order.

Sunflower Cupcakes
Dark chocolate cupcakes iced in vanilla buttercream and decorated with an Oreo cookie Sunflower or two! You may   even find a few exploring M&M ladybugs. $2.25/each

Centerpiece Cake
Our delicious pumpkin spice cake is iced in vanilla buttercream. Decorated with fall flowers and real candles, this cake makes the perfect Thanksgiving table centerpiece. Large 16″ long cake (pictured) serves about 20, $55.00. Medium 8″ long cake serves about 10, $40.00.

Harvest Cut-Outs
A collection of assorted shapes including pumpkins, different fruits, and leaves. $12.00/dozen

Pumpkin Spice Bread
Thanksgiving wouldn’t be complete without a loaf or two of this traditional sweet bread! $8.50/loaf

Harvest Cake

Our classic vanilla cake is iced in chocolate fudge buttercream, decorated with an intricate basketweave design, and edged with gorgeous buttercream flowers. 8″ round serves about 15~ $45.00

Pie Cupcakes
These darling vanilla cupcakes are topped with cherries and iced in vanilla buttercream. The kids will love this version of “pie”! $2.00/each.

Pilgrim Cut-Outs
A delightful assortment of Pilgrims, Indians, leaves,  pumpkins, and turkeys! $14.00/dozen

Halloween is only two weeks away! Contact us today to place your order.

Monster Cupcakes

This group of Frankenstein and friends won’t last long!

Available in dark chocolate or vanilla cake, iced in buttercream.

$2.25/each, minimum order 6, please.

Jack-O-Lantern Cakes

These friendly vanilla pumpkins
are sure to thrill the kids or any delighted recipient!

Each serves 1-2. $7.50/each

Mrs. Frankenstein Cake

This dark chocolate cake is iced in vanilla buttercream

and decorated to look like a typical monster’s happy wife!

Serves about 15 - $40.00.

(Also available- smaller version which serves about 8, $25.00)

Halloween Cut-Outs

A mix of our famous decorated butter cookies in holiday shapes:

Frankensteins, witches, spider webs, jack-o-lanterns, werewolves, and ghosts.

$12.00/dozen

Spiderweb Cupcakes

Little icing spiders spin a licorice web above

an assortment of chocolate and vanilla cupcakes iced in vanilla buttercream.

Serves 19, $30.00. (Also available- smaller version which serves 7, $13.00)

Spooky Brownies

Our delicious from-scratch chocolate fudge brownies are cut

into fun shapes and decorated as mummies, cats, coffins, bats, and skeletons.

$9.00/dozen

Chocolate Strawberry Shortcake

Loads of fresh strawberries and blueberries surround

a double layer dark chocolate cake, topped with

plenty of real whipped cream and even more berries!

8″ round * serves about 12-16 ~ $45.00

Cut-Out Cookies
A colorful array of red, white, and blue stars surround the “U.S.A.”! $12.00/dozen

Celebration Cake
This patriotic confection is our moist white cake,

layered with red raspberry filling, and iced in our signature vanilla buttercream.

8″ round * serves about 12-16 ~ $45.00

Sparkler Cupcakes
Vanilla cupcakes iced in white vanilla buttercream,

decorated with red and blue buttercream polka dots,

and set off by some fun “fireworks”! $2.00/each

Star Cakes

One of these star cakes would certainly delight any wide-eyed recipient!

Vanilla cake iced and decorated in red, white, and blue vanilla buttercream.

Each serves 1-2. $7.00/each

*cakes also available in larger or smaller sizes