The Upper Crust | Penfield, NY

EXTENDED STORE HOURS FOR THANKSGIVING WEEK

MONDAY 10:00AM - 6:00PM

TUESDAY 10:00AM - 6:00PM

WEDNESDAY 10:00AM - 6:00PM

THURSDAY - CLOSED

FRIDAY - CLOSED

SATURDAY 10:00AM - 6:00PM

Oreo-Sunflower, Friendly-Fowl & “Pie” Cupcakes

standard-size $2.50/each

Feel free to stop by and pick out some goodies from our display case!

Cut-Outs $1.00 - $1.50/each

Pumpkin Spice Bread $8.75/loaf

We intend to have all 10 flavors of our Colossal Cupcakes, mini cupcake Samplers, as well a whole bunch of Thanksgiving Specials similar to what you see here.

It’s not too late to order for your Easter celebration this weekend! Contact us now to place your order, or just stop by this weekend to pick out items from our display case.

Hours: Wednesday thru Saturday, 10:00am - 6:00pm

email: orders@uppercrustcakes.com | phone: 585.385.2253

Easter Celebration Cakes

Set one of our beautiful and delicious cakes as your Easter table centerpiece; we’re sure it will make everyone smile! Choose your cake/icing flavors, and select from three cake designs (Easter Bunny, Spring Flowers, or Easter Cookie-Egg Basket).

6″ single-torte, serves about 6, $25.00

8″ single-torte, serves about 10, $40.00

8″ double-torte, serves about 16, $55.00

Cut-Out Cookie Collections

We designed three different sets of cutouts to pair with your Easter celebration, whether you want a traditional, fun & silly, or meaningful theme!

Classic Easter (bunny, carrot, flower, Easter basket, egg with hatching chick) $15.00/dz

Silly Eggs & Bunnies (bright colors with googly eyes/faces) $15.00/dz

Resurrection Sunrise (crosses, tomb/stone, palm trees, angels, sunrise, Mary Magdalene, “He Is Risen!”) $18.00/dz

Easter Cupcakes

Select from two designs: Easter Friends (Buried Bunnies, Chicks, and Egg Nests) or Spring Flowers

Standard-size, white vanilla cake iced in vanilla buttercream.

$15.00 box of six

Cinnamon Sensations

Our famous “sticky buns” are overflowing with cinnamon sugar and real butter, and topped with a lavish swirl of creamy icing. These also freeze very well, so order a few extra to stash away!

$2.50/each

Visit our FaceBoook page to view our specials!

We will be open on Valentine’s Day (Mon Feb 14)

11:00am - 4:00pm

Swing by anytime, to pickup some of our holiday specialities to share with your sweetie.

We’re still accepting orders for Christmas! Next week (Christmas week) we will be open Tuesday - Friday, 8:00am - 6:00pm.

We also have most items available for purchase in-store, during regular business hours.

Centerpiece Cakes

Use one of these beautiful cakes for your holiday  centerpiece, or bring one to the upcoming work party! We also have larger sizes available.

Poinsettia Design, Snowflake Design, or Snowman Design*

6″ single torte, serves about 4-6, $20.00

6″ double torte, serves about 8, $35.00

* add $5.00.

Miniature Cupcake Assortment

This is a collection of all ten flavors of our Colossal Cupcakes, simply a smaller version of each! Vanilla, Chocolate, Twist, Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Lemon Raspberry, Pollyanna, Carrot, Pumpkin Spice, and Black & White. $18.00/box

Holiday Assortment Tray

Featuring a dozen each of our mini cupcakes (see above), small chocolate and peppermint-frosted brownie squares, and Winter Cut-Outs, this is perfect for an office thank-you or neighborly gift. Medium  12″ tray serves about 12, $50.00.

Nativity Cut-Out Collection

A very special family of three is surrounded by wooly sheep, angels and stars! $18.00/dz

Christmas Classics

We bring you some of our family’s favorite Christmas-time cookie traditions: Hershey’s Chocolate Hugs, Peanut-Butter Blossoms, Rum-Spice Logs, Raspberry Shortbread, and CrinkleMint sandwiches. $9.00/dz

Rudolph & Friends Cut-Out Collection

Inspired by the annual television special, we proudly present Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, Hermie the Elf, Mr Sam Snowman, Yukon Cornelius, and of course the Abominable Snow Monster, all in delightful cookie form! $18.00/dozen

Santa & Friends Cut-Out Collection

The kids will love this fun cookie collection, including Santa, his sleigh, and all 9 of his reliable reindeer (Rudolph, too!).  $18.00/dozen

Assorted Christmas Classics Cookie Tins

Can’t find the time to make those cookies for the neighbors or co-workers? Save yourself some trouble and order some of these ready-to-give gifts. We package a lovely assortment of our Christmas Classics, (plus some Cut-Outs too!) in a light blue tin with see-through lid and finish with silver Christmas ribbon.

[ Small White Box, 8 cookies, $7.00 ]

Medium Tin, 18 cookies, $16.00

Large Tin, 36 cookies, $31.00

Winter Cut-Out Collection

One of our most popular collections, these classic Christmas designs are sure to put a smile on everyone’s face. Including snowman, stocking, tree, mitten, and gingerbread house shapes, these make an impressive dessert or even intriguing place setting markers! $18.00/dozen

Ornament Cut-Out Collection

These cookies come in a variety of ornament shapes and are decorated in an elegant color scheme with hunter green, holly-berry red, and deep purple. $15.00/dozen

Snowflake Cut-Out Collection

These snowflake cookies come in a assortment of varying sizes and shapes. They are iced in white and pale blue buttercream, and are decorated with sparking sugar “snow crystals” or hand piped snowflake designs. $15.00/dozen

Please note that we recommend storing the cutout cookies in the refrigerator or freezer, as the cold temperatures will best preserve the icing decorations. (The buttercream tends to soften at room temp.) You can take them directly out to serve at the last possible moment or display ahead of time in a single layer without stacking.

OUR NEW LOCATION HAS SPECIAL HOURS FOR THANKSGIVING WEEK!

Although our normal business hours are Wed-Sat (8am-6pm), we’re offering an extended schedule this week because of the Thanksgiving holiday.

We are open Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday for you to stop by for some holiday treats; as well as Friday and Saturday. We are closed on Thanksgiving Day (Thursday).

Our hours are the same every day that we are open: 8:00am - 6:00pm.

Please note we are completely booked for special orders through this weekend. So instead, feel free to stop by and pick out some goodies from our display cases! We intend to have all 10 flavors of our Colossal Cupcakes, as well as Harvest & Pilgrim cut-out cookies, our Pumpkin Spice bread, and some Thanksgiving Centerpiece cakes, too. Come check it out!

We have an overabundance of Easter and Spring Flower cut-out cookies! It’s not too late to pick some up for this weekend.

Give us a call or email us anytime to snag some of our extra treats for your family. You’ll be glad you did!

It’s not too late to order for your Easter celebration this weekend! Contact us now to place your order.

Easter Cake

Try this happy buttercream-bunny cake as your table centerpiece; we’re sure it will make everyone smile!

8″ round serves about 15 ~ $45.00

Easter Collection

This assortment of Easter eggs, bunnies, carrots, and Easter basket cut-out cookies is guaranteed to brighten your Easter celebration!

$15.00/dozen

Easter Cupcakes

These fun cupcakes are decorated with little Easter eggs, buried bunnies, and some just-hatched chicks!

$2.25/each (half dozen minimum, please)

Cross & Hydrangea Cake

Matching the focus of this Easter season, this single-layer cake is stacked with a small cross cake and decorated with beautiful hydrangea, apple blossom, and rose sugar flowers.

10″ torte serves about 15 ~ $45.00

Celebration Cake

This two-layer vanilla cake is iced in our vanilla buttercream and decorated with a variety of sugar flowers as a beautiful spring wreath.

8″ round serves about 15 ~ $45.00

Spring Flower Collection

An exquisite collection of spring daisies and apple blossom cut-out cookies (varying sizes).

$10.00/dozen

Cinnamon Sensations

Our famous “sticky buns” are overflowing with cinnamon sugar and real butter, and topped with a lavish swirl of creamy icing. These also freeze very well, so order a few extra to stash away!

$2.25/each (half dozen minimum, please)

Valentine’s Day is Sunday, February 14! Order today to surprise your Valentine.

Valentine Cutout Collection

These heart shaped butter cookies are decorated with sparkling sugar, sprinkles, and delicate buttercream detailing. $14.00/dozen (varying sizes)

Giant CupCake

Watch the kids’ eyes go wide when you set this on the table! It’s a HUGE cupcake-shaped cake iced in light chocolate buttercream and decorated with red, pink, and white hearts. About 7″ high, serves about 10 ~ $20.00.

Letters & Love Cutout Collection

Send a little love to someone special. . . what could be better than a mix of hearts, romantic love letters, and “I Love You” hand cookies? $18.00/dozen

Ice Cream Sundae Cupcakes

Each of these sweet treats is really a vanilla cupcake crowned with a “scoop” of vanilla or chocolate buttercream, and finished with some sprinkles and a “cherry”! $3.50/each (half dozen minimum, please)

Ganache Cupcakes

For these impressive little guys, we began with chocolate cupcakes hand-dipped in semisweet chocolate ganache icing. We then piped swirly, romantic messages and pretty buttercream flowers to finish them off. You’ll be the perfect Hostess with these! $2.25/each (half dozen minimum, please)

Hearts & Sprinkles Cupcakes

For a little Valentine’s Day snack, how ’bout a big chomp out of one of these babies! Chocolate cupcakes are iced in light-pink buttercream and decorated with sprinkles. $1.50/each (half dozen minimum, please)

Need some extra Christmas treats or gifts?

We still have some items available! Check it out:

Rudolph & Friends Cut-Out cookie collection (see photo below), $18/dz

Poinsettia Mini-cupcakes (box of 9 assorted, $10)

Christmas Treat Boxes - each containing 9 small size mint-brownies and 4 assorted chocolate & vanilla poinsettia cupcakes, $10

Available for pickup (appointments) on Thursday morning, Dec 24 ~ Christmas Eve.