The Upper Crust | Penfield, NY

We will be closed for Christmas and the following week (Friday Dec 25- Sun Jan 3). Contact us in the New Year for your next occasion!

Merry Christmas!

Need some extra Christmas treats or gifts?

We still have some items available! Check it out:

Rudolph & Friends Cut-Out cookie collection (see photo below), $18/dz

Poinsettia Mini-cupcakes (box of 9 assorted, $10)

Christmas Treat Boxes - each containing 9 small size mint-brownies and 4 assorted chocolate & vanilla poinsettia cupcakes, $10

Available for pickup (appointments) on Thursday morning, Dec 24 ~ Christmas Eve.

Contact us today to place your holiday order. Limited quantities available.

Rudolph & Friends Cut-Out Collection

Inspired by the annual televsion special, we proudly present Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, Hermie the Elf, Mr Sam Snowman, Yukon Cornelius, and of course the Abominable Snow Monster, all in delightful cookie form! $18.00/dozen*

Snowflake Cut-Out Collection

Perfect to share with the neighbors or bring to a holiday gathering, these snowflake cookies come in a assortment of varying sizes and shapes. They are iced in white and pale blue buttercream, and are decorated with sparking sugar “snow crystals” or hand piped snowflake designs. $15.00/dozen*

Ornament Cut-Out Collection

These cookies come in a variety of ornament shapes and are decorated in an elegant color scheme with hunter green, golden yellow, holly-berry red, deep purple, and sky blue. $15.00/dozen*

Winter Cut-Out Collection

One of our favorite collections this year, these classic Christmas designs are sure to put a smile on everyone’s face. Including Frosty the Snowman, stocking, candy cane, mitten, and gingerbread house designs, these cookies make an impressive dessert tray display or even intriguing place setting markers! $18.00/dozen*

Poinsetta Mini Cupcakes

These little cuties are just right for the company party or to surprise the mailman! Available in classic white or dark chocolate cake, we ice these mini cupcakes in a generous swirl of buttercream and then top them off with a pretty red, white, or pink poinsetta. $9.00/half dozen