The Upper Crust | Penfield, NY

Bunny Cupcakes

The kids will love these! Each vanilla cupcake is iced in vanilla buttercream, and decorated with a bunny cut-out cookie holding an armful of candy carrots.

Each serves 1. $2.75/each. Half dozen minimum, please.

Cinnamon Sensations

Our famous “sticky buns” are overflowing with cinnamon sugar and real butter, and topped with a lavish swirl of creamy icing. These also freeze very well, so order a few extra to stash away!

$2.25/each. Half dozen minimum, please.

Easter Basket Cake

This unique, 3-dimensional creation is actually two layers of moist carrot cake, decorated in a basketweave pattern with cream cheese icing, and topped with Easter egg cut-out cookies! Wonderful as a table centerpiece. (Also available in alternate cake/icing flavors.)

6″ round serves about 10 ~ $35.00

8″ round serves about 20 ~ $45.00

Lemon Poppyseed Bread

Made with real lemons and a generous amount of poppy seeds, this light, flavorful sweet bread is perfect to complement your Easter brunch or dinner.

Large loaf (yields 8-10 slices) ~ $8.75

Easter Cut-Outs

An exquisite assortment of Easter eggs, bunnies, carrots, and daisy flowers is guaranteed to brighten your Easter celebration!

$12.00/dozen

Celebration Cake

This vanilla cake is iced in our vanilla buttercream and decorated with a variety of sugar flowers as a beautiful spring wreath.

8″ round serves about 15 ~ $45.00

Cookie Assortment

Lemon bar squares, raspberry shortbread cookies, and a smaller version of our delicious cut-out daisies make up this appealing assortment of bite-size spring treats.

Available boxed or trayed ~ $7.00/dozen . 2 dozen minimum, please

St. Patrick’s Day is next Tuesday, March 17!

Rainbow Cake

With a colorful cut-out cookie rainbow and marshmallow pot ‘o gold, this happy cake is sure to delight all your family or friends! 6″ two-layer round serves about 6-8, $35.00

Shamrock Cupcakes

These vanilla cupcakes are baked in gold liners, iced with a generous swirl of vanilla buttercream, and decorated with some jolly St. Patrick’s Day shamrock sprinkles. $1.50/each (half dozen minimum, please)

Mint-Frosted Brownies

One of our most popular desserts, these luscious little goodies are home-made brownie squares iced in mint buttercream and served in shamrock-themed papers. $5.00/dozen (apprx. 1″ squares- two dozen minimum, please)

Lucky Cut-Outs

Here’s a fun holiday mix of shamrocks, rainbows, pots o’ gold, and pointy-eared leprechauns! $12.00/dozen

Lately we’ve been exploring new designs in the world of cupcakes. Here are some of our latest creations:

These confetti cake cupcakes are iced in vanilla buttercream, decorated with a birthday inscription, and edged with rainbow “jimmy” sprinkles.

We created these sleeping beauties for a sleep-over party. They are vanilla cake iced in vanilla buttercream, then decorated with a variety of cookies and candies. We used marshmallows for pillows, mini Nilla wafers for heads, Teddy Graham bears, Jelly Belly “feet”, and rolled out Starbursts & AirHeads for the blankets. They were a huge hit at the party! Here are few more shots closer up.

We did these vanilla cupcakes (iced in chocolate fudge buttercream) with a colorfulfashion theme. Half of them had a pair of pink fondant stilettos studded with pastel sprinkle flowers. We edged the rest of the cupcakes with matching pastel sprinkles and personalized them with the birthday girl’s initial.

We were inspired by some of our (many!) idea books, for several of these designs. (See, we can’t take all the credit!) Here are some of our favorite books, if you’re up for a challenge! Don’t forget, you can always eat any of your “mistakes”.

The Confetti Cakes Cookbook by Elisa Strauss of New York City’s Confetti Cakes

Hello, Cupcake! by Karen Tack & Alan Richardson

(Hello, Cupcake! is one of our top-favorites, a recently released book for the amateur or professional baker. Highly recommended.)

Cupcake Fun! by Wilton Industries